Principles of Sportsmanship
Before I get started I'll first explain how my personal sportsmanship code while playing games. I play to the best of my ability, to the natural end of the game no matter how it might be going for me, with respect to my opponent, and I always shake their hand afterwards. I've won my fair share of best sportsman awards at events, the largest being at the 40k The Friendly Tournament at Adepticon.
Having played in a variety of sports from age 5 until high school good sportsmanship was an easily identifiable thing. You play to the best of your ability with respect to your opponent during the game and line up and shake hands after it's all said and done. Now, there is always the exception to the "playing to the best of your ability" part of that. When your pounding the other team into the dirt, it's always polite to not play your absolute best players, try out some new plays, etc. The principle of sportsmanship is easily translatable to every single sport, BUT for some reason the wargaming community seems to have difficulty with this.
As there are many different approaches to wargaming I'll break it up into a few different categories since I believe wargaming sportsmanship does change depending on what environment you're playing in.
Pick-Up Games
Going into a store or club and playing someone completely random. Could be a complete stranger or could be a good friend, but this was not a prearranged narrative game and you're not playing in a tournament. Just a couple of guys (or gals) that are looking to play with your toy soldiers. Here is how I would define good sportsmanship in this scenario:
- Play with respect to your opponent
- Play to the best of your ability
- Shake hands after the game
Alright, pretty easy to understand, right? With #2 there is going to be some lee-way if you have a demanding lead in victory points. Should you wish to ease up and not play to the best of your ability, I believe that's perfectly acceptable, but in the end that's up to the individual. Either way, if you play following these tenants you'll get a tip of the hat from me good sir.
Narrative Games
These you don't see happening in the stores or clubs very often, but I have a feeling they are the predominant mode of playing games for all of our basement-dwelling wargamers (and I don't mean that they live with their parents, that's just where the games generally take place). Here is how I would define good sportsmanship while role-playing you're favorite character on the tabletop:
- Play with respect to your opponent
- Play to the best of your ability
- Shake hands after the game
Yep, nothing changed from pick-up games, but I'm guessing you're not surprised with that. In regards to #2 you could play that depending characteristics of the general being fielded on the tabletop. Would a bloodthirsty rampaging vampire let the poor beleaguered guard flee the battlefield? HELL NO! (Well, at least my bloodthirsty rampaging vampires don't...unless you're into Twilight or something...) What's cool about this though is that you can reflect you're characters attitude in your style of play. Should you're noble honorable knight think it dishonorable to kill every single peasant in enemy village, so be it, stay your sword good knight!
Tournament Games
Be it a one-day, two-day, weekend, 10 player, or 100 player event a tournament is a tournament. You're attending for the competition to see who can come out on top. This is how I would define good sportsmanship in this scenario:
- Play with respect to your opponent
- Play to the best of your ability
- Shake hands after the game
Huh, that's odd. Nothing changed. That's right folks! The tenants of sportsmanship don't really change at all! Addressing #2, I would say in a tournament situation you don't have to worry about easing up on your opponent. You play to the best of ability and give it your all the entire event. Especially if it's scored on the 20-0 scale you don't get bonus points for easing up on your opponent, so feel free blast away until all that's left of your opponents army is some shoes smoldering in a crater. This doesn't mean you have to play like an asshole, whooping and hollering when you do well and crying like a giant-asshole baby when you don't, but you just play smartly and don't hold anything back.
What I Don't Agree With
There are a lot of things that I see around on the interwebs and blogs that I don't agree with at all. For example, two of the things I see commonly are playing the kind of game your opponent wants to play; not choosing certain lores or spells because to do so would be unsportsmanlike; and the whole concept of sportsmanship and composition being confused in event scoring.
Playing the game your opponent wants to play.
I'm assuming this is saying that don't play a casual pick-up game with a tournament game mentality, but if not, it's not on you to make sure that your opponent is having a good time (of course while being a polite, courteous, and decent human being) it's up to your opponent to do that for themselves! If they are upset because a unit that they thought would win them the game got blown of the table and start complaining and whining about it, guess what, it's them that's being unsportsmanlike! Not you for killing the most valuable high-priority target! They should stop crying and get back to playing the game. Maybe this hobby has more than the average amount of man-children, but this is something that I see a lot that I find incredibly infuriating. Maybe I'll rant about that at a later time though.
Not choosing certain lores or spells.
While I agree that certain lores/spells have definite advantages over others (looking at you Purple Sun and Dwellers) to just have them in your arsenal and perhaps use them is not in itself unsportsmanlike. In fact, these spells are one of the main, and sometimes only, tools that a player has to deal with deathstar units. While I agree it would be silly to pronounce your prowess of a game due to your ability to roll dice for a specific spell, I don't think that it's unsportsmanlike.
Sportsmanship/Comp Scoring
Again, here is something else that it's own post, but I'll try to summarize. Sportsmanship and comp should be scored in completely different categories; however, I've found in many of the events that I've attended that they are not. One question commonly asked is "Rate how much you'd like to play this player again", now what army that player has an effect on their opponent. Did they just get tabled? Do they not enjoy playing against their opponent army? Well, then they might rate their opponent low for that question; however, that does not address their opponents sportsmanship! At all! The questions that should be asked in the sportsmanship section are the following: "How many times did your opponent complain about his/her dice?" "How many times did your opponent curse at you?" "How many times did your opponent throw dice or models?" Alas, they do not.